Books on the Bedside Table

Tombland
Scotland A Concise History
Frances Partridge
Gallows Court
Go Saddle The Sea
The Travellers Guide to Classical Philosophy
Oxford Companion to the Brontes Anniversary edition
The Hired Man

  • Instagram

  • Search Our Books for Sale via Biblio

Favourite Crime

Blog powered by Typepad

« New blogs, blog a Penguin, and more... | Main | Back in Action »

July 19, 2008

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Thanks for linking to my post and letting me know your review is up! I was skeptical about this series, but I think I'll give it a try, as your review does make it sound like something I'd like.
Personally, I prefer when historical fiction writers let people of their time be what they were. I feel like my intelligence is being insulted when authors assume I can't like a hero who doesn't share my own modern values or that I can't embrace a world that isn't, say, as diverse as my own. Dorothy Dunnett is probably the best I've found at immersing her readers entirely into a different time. Any embracing of contemporary values seems organic to the story and the characters, rather than pandering to today's readers.

This is nothing to do with your review (which is very good, I might add) but actually just to say thanks for mentioning my blog on the Guardian site today! Very nice of you!

Teresa - yes, it really is worth a read. I too prefer the most authentic atmosphere, and prefer modern norms not to be overly pandered to in inappropriate ways. I think that the worst example of pc ridden historical writing I have seen is The Secret River by Kate Grenville. I haven't read and Dorothy Dunnett, though I know one of my ibooknet colleagues is a big fan (the nice lady at The Old Bookshelf), and I keep meaning to try Dunnett out. I will make haste to do so!

Kirsty - you're welcome!

Interesting post. I tend to shy away from historical fiction for many of the reasons you've listed above. I'd rather read something actually written during the period if I can or a history. There are so many popular histories now, just about one for everything you can think of.

The comments to this entry are closed.

Book Care and Repair

CL Hawley Books

  • A small selection of our recent stock ...
17900
17825
Bay of Ghosts
14088
14546
15611
17189

UK Book Fairs

Become a Fan

Bookmark and Share